Sign Up | See BetterPitch Samples | Work With Us

Hello PitchDeckGuy readers!

In today's breakdown, we're taking a comprehensive look at Ares Management's Q4 2023 pitch to the Pennsylvania State Employees' Retirement System for their fourth U.S. Real Estate Opportunity Fund (AREOF IV). This analysis reveals how one of the world's leading investment managers approached institutional fundraising during one of the most challenging market environments in recent memory.

In this deep dive, we'll examine three key aspects of their pitch:

First, we'll explore the crucial market context of late 2023, including the unprecedented $1.2T commercial real estate debt wall and broader market dynamics that made this pitch particularly significant. 

Then, we'll break down their pitch architecture slide by slide, analyzing how they established credibility, framed market opportunities, and presented their investment strategy. 

Finally, we'll dissect why this pitch worked so effectively, exploring how Ares positioned their platform advantages and risk management approach to resonate with institutional investors in uncertain times.

Context and Market Environment

When Ares presented AREOF IV with its ambitious $3.0 billion target raise in Q4 2023, they did so from a position of remarkable institutional strength. By December 31st, 2023, the firm had expanded their assets under management to $419 billion - a 19% increase from the previous year. This growth trajectory reflected a broader transformation, as Ares had evolved from its founding focus on leveraged loans and high-yield bonds to become a diversified alternative investment powerhouse.

By late 2023, their platform was serving over 2,300 institutional investors and hundreds of thousands of individual investors, demonstrating both their institutional quality and broad market acceptance.

This institutional strength proved particularly valuable given the challenging market environment of late 2023. While many managers struggled with fundraising and deployment, Ares demonstrated remarkable resilience by deploying nearly $70 billion in capital during the year. Their success was especially pronounced in private credit, where they maintained their position as the top global manager, commanding over $285 billion in credit assets. This scale and expertise positioned them well to navigate the complex market dynamics ahead.

The late 2023 investment landscape presented an unprecedented confluence of challenges and opportunities: 

Private equity was experiencing its worst year since 2016, with deal activity plummeting across all segments. Real estate transaction volumes had fallen to their lowest levels since 2013, creating a backdrop of uncertainty…but also framing potential opportunity for well-capitalized players with proven execution capabilities.

Property owners across the board faced an unprecedented wall of debt - approximately $1.2 trillion in loans requiring refinancing by 2025. This refinancing challenge emerged during a period of dramatic market divergence: real estate stocks had declined 19% while the broader stock market surged 29%. For institutional investors like pension funds, this divergence created both opportunity and an understandable anxiety. The potential for attractive entry points was clear…but timing your market entry is always much easier said than done.

What made this environment particularly noteworthy was the dramatic contrast between public market signals and private market fundamentals. 

The divergence reached historic levels in late 2023, with office REITs trading at a 44.1% discount to NAV, hotel REITs at a 32.9% discount, and regional mall REITs at a 28.4% discount. Only casino and data center REITs maintained slight premiums to NAV, at 3.5% and 3.2% respectively.

The scale of this public-private market disconnect was unprecedented. In Q3 2022, the difference between public and private market returns reached its widest point in index history, with the FTSE Nareit All Equity Index and the NFI-ODCE posting a dramatic 38.4% performance gap. By November 2023, conditions had begun to moderate, with publicly listed REITs trading at a median discount of 20%, an improvement from the 28% discount seen the previous month.

Historical analysis provided important context for this dislocation. Examination of eight similar trough periods since 2000 revealed a consistent pattern: following periods of significant REIT underperformance (defined as -10% or greater), public REITs typically outperformed private real estate by substantial margins, achieving average returns of 41.8% compared to 4.6% for private real estate. 

This pattern, combined with NAREIT research showing that REIT valuations typically lead private market valuations by 6 to 18 months, created a compelling opportunity set for investors with the expertise to capitalize on these dislocations.

This market dynamic was particularly relevant for institutional investors. Public REITs offered access to institutional-quality properties with best-in-class operators at substantial discounts to private market valuations. Historical data from Green Street reinforced the significance of these valuation gaps - their research showed that for 96% of the time between 1998 and 2018, property prices appreciated within 12 months following periods where public REITs traded at premiums to NAV, with the inverse holding true during discount periods.

In retrospect, the institutional investment landscape during this period reflected a careful balance between caution and opportunism. 

Many institutional investors found themselves overallocated to real estate due to the denominator effect, as declining public market valuations pushed their private market allocations above target ranges. But the same market dynamics that created these allocation challenges also presented compelling opportunities for those with available capital…

If and only if they were also blessed with the expertise to deploy this capital effectively.

This broader market context made Ares' positioning particularly compelling. They had run both organic growth and strategic acquisitions, and they had built a platform capable of evaluating and executing complex opportunities across markets and strategies. Their private credit franchise had grown to become the largest in the world, providing crucial advantages in assessing and executing real estate opportunities, particularly those involving distressed debt or special situations.

The sophistication of Ares' approach becomes clear when you look at their pitch in detail. They faced a massive challenge:

Crafting a presentation that would resonate with institutional investors wrestling with market uncertainty, portfolio allocation decisions, and the need for managers who could both identify opportunities and execute with discipline. 

Their response to these challenges offers valuable lessons for any institution raising capital in difficult markets. 

The stage is set! Let’s dive in…

The Pitch Architecture: A Slide-by-Slide Breakdown

Opening & Credibility

Ares opened their pitch with a masterful demonstration of institutional credibility, a strategic choice that accomplished several key objectives at once. 

By leading with their institutional profile rather than market opportunities, they immediately signaled to pension fund investors that they understood the paramount importance of stability and governance. This approach also cleverly differentiated them from newer, less established managers who might lead with returns or opportunities, subtly reinforcing Ares' position as a mature, institutional-quality partner. 

Opening with platform strength created an instant and irrefutable foundation of trust that made their subsequent market observations and strategy proposals far more credible. 

Their status as a NYSE-listed entity with a $30.2 billion market capitalization provided immediate validation of their governance and transparency. The presentation of their $378 billion AUM and global footprint of 2,640 employees across 35+ offices established both scale and expertise before slapping investors in the face with opportunity.

Another important reason this opening sequence resonated was Ares' recent expansion into new markets and strategies. By late 2023, they were serving over 2,300 institutional investors and hundreds of thousands of individual investors, demonstrating both institutional quality and broad market acceptance. Their NYSE listing provided an additional layer of transparency and governance oversight that particularly appealed to public pension fund investors. 

Put simply, Ares' opening gambit boiled down to a powerful message: 

"We're big, we're stable, and we're highly regulated - you can trust us with your capital." 

This straightforward yet sophisticated approach laid the groundwork for everything that followed in their pitch.

Market Context

Rather than shying away from market challenges, Ares presented a detailed analysis of market conditions that balanced risks and opportunities. Their treatment of inflation trends and inverted yield curves provided crucial context for their investment thesis. The analysis included several key components that resonated with institutional investors:

First, they provided detailed analysis of REIT price movements versus broader market performance, highlighting potential disconnects between public and private markets. This analysis demonstrated both the challenges facing the sector and the opportunities created by market dislocation.

Second, they presented GDP resilience metrics that suggested underlying economic strength despite market volatility. This data helped support their thesis that market stress was creating tactical opportunities in fundamentally sound assets.

Third, they offered specific data points on transaction volume declines and their implications for pricing. This analysis helped frame the opportunity set while acknowledging the challenges of price discovery in a low-volume environment.

Opportunity Framework

Ares structured their opportunity set around six carefully defined categories, each supported by specific market dynamics and executable strategies:

Their Direct RE Lending strategy capitalized on the retreat of traditional lenders from the market, particularly regional banks facing their own balance sheet challenges. This opportunity was enhanced by Ares' position as the world's largest private credit manager. The advantage here is easy to see: the more access to unique insights into borrower needs and market pricing, the better.

The Gap Capital strategy targeted situations where traditional financing sources proved insufficient, particularly in complex transactions requiring speed and certainty of execution. Ares' ability to provide flexible capital across the capital structure positioned them remarkably well for these opportunities.

Their approach to Forced Sellers focused specifically on opportunities arising from the $1.2 trillion refinancing wall, with particular emphasis on quality assets facing short-term capital structure challenges rather than fundamental operational issues.

The Discounted Assets strategy focused on public market dislocations, particularly where public REIT prices had declined more severely than private market valuations would suggest. This approach leveraged Ares' expertise in both public and private markets – a subtly brilliant reinforcement of the frame established at the beginning of the deck. 

Their Distressed-to-Own strategy leveraged Ares' credit expertise to identify situations where debt positions could lead to eventual ownership at attractive bases. This strategy particularly benefited from their extensive credit research capabilities and restructuring expertise.

The Corporate Situations strategy targeted real estate owned by non-real estate companies, particularly where corporate balance sheet pressure created motivated sellers. This approach leveraged Ares' broader corporate relationships and private equity expertise.

Real quick...

Your market opportunity deserves an institutional-quality presentation. BetterPitch has created over 316 successful pitches across 17 industries, and we've earned a 96/100 client satisfaction rating along the way. Let us help you craft a pitch that captures your opportunity

Strategy Deep Dive

The presentation of their three-pillar investment strategy demonstrated sophisticated market understanding and execution capability:

Their approach to Distressed and Special Situations leveraged Ares' unique position as a leading credit manager with over $285 billion allocated to private credit investments. For institutional investors, this strategy resonated on multiple levels. 

The combination of real estate expertise and credit capabilities suggested an ability to see around corners in distressed situations, while their scale promised the financial capacity to execute complex transactions. 

This dual capability particularly appealed to investors who recognized that the approaching refinancing wall would require managers capable of evaluating both real estate fundamentals and complex capital structures. By positioning themselves at the intersection of credit and real estate, Ares offered investors a compelling narrative about capturing opportunity while managing risk.

The Enhance and Reposition strategy focused on operational improvement opportunities, leveraging Ares' extensive network of operating partners and their track record of successful repositioning projects. 

This strategy spoke directly to sophisticated investors' understanding that in a market reset, financial engineering alone would not drive returns. 

By emphasizing their operator relationships and hands-on approach to value creation, Ares differentiated themselves from purely financial buyers. The strategy particularly resonated with investors who had experienced previous market cycles and understood that operational expertise becomes critically important when market momentum can no longer be relied upon for appreciation.

Their Development of Core-Quality Assets strategy demonstrated deep understanding of supply-demand dynamics across markets, with a focus on creating institutional-quality assets in supply-constrained markets. For institutional investors, this strategy offered a compelling blend of defense and offense. 

The emphasis on supply-constrained markets addressed concerns about overbuilding, while the focus on institutional-quality assets spoke to long-term portfolio considerations.

Their conservative underwriting and pre-leasing requirements provided additional comfort to investors who might otherwise be wary of development risk in an uncertain market.

This approach positioned Ares as a disciplined steward of capital while still maintaining exposure to potentially higher-returning development opportunities.

Why This Pitch Works

The details are nuanced and complicated, but the reasons this deck worked are easy to spot:

A careful balance of authority, opportunity, and risk management. 

Every platform advantage was positioned through a risk management lens, creating particular appeal for institutional investors in an uncertain market environment.

Their extensive network of local market teams provided crucial risk mitigation through deep market knowledge and relationships. These teams offered both proprietary deal flow and granular market intelligence. And it adds up to a formidable arsenal for executing complex strategies in a challenging market.

The four-year deployment window demonstrated patient capital deployment discipline while maintaining flexibility to capitalize on market dislocations. This timeline aligned well with their expectation of increasing opportunity as the refinancing wall approached.

Their programmatic joint venture relationships ensured proprietary deal flow while reducing execution risk through trusted partnerships. These relationships proved particularly valuable in a market where access to off-market opportunities provided significant advantage.

Ares' platform scale provided certainty of execution in an uncertain market. This scale allowed them to pursue opportunities across markets and strategies while maintaining strong risk management practices.

Their track record of institutional fundraising success provided important validation, with $74 billion raised in 2023 despite challenging market conditions. This fundraising success demonstrated both investor confidence in their platform and their ability to execute in difficult markets.

The successful expansion of their wealth management channel demonstrated their ability to diversify their investor base while maintaining institutional quality standards. This diversification provided additional stability to their platform while creating potential co-investment opportunities for institutional investors.

Their conservative approach to leverage, maintaining a maximum loan-to-value ratio of 62%, particularly resonated with institutional investors concerned about market volatility. This conservative approach to capital structure provided important downside protection while still allowing for attractive returns.

A Clinic in Institutional Fundraising

At the end of the day, this presentation's success lies in its careful orchestration of multiple elements that together create a compelling investment narrative.

The significance in timing of this pitch can’t be overstated. The late 2023 real estate market challenges – a looming $1.2 trillion refinancing wall, historic public-private market dislocations, and transaction volumes at their lowest levels since 2013 – seemed near-insurmountable at the time. 

But Ares transformed these challenges into opportunities through careful positioning and strategic insight.

Their approach demonstrated a deep understanding of institutional investor psychology. They began with platform strength and stability—precisely what pension funds need to hear first—before methodically building their case for market opportunity. This sequencing created a foundation of trust that made their subsequent market observations and strategic proposals more credible.

The presentation's treatment of market dynamics showed particular sophistication. Rather than simply highlighting distress, they presented a nuanced view of market dislocations and their implications. Their analysis of public-private market divergence, backed by historical precedent and recovery patterns, provided institutional investors with both context and comfort.

Perhaps most importantly, Ares positioned their platform advantages not as mere capabilities, but as risk mitigants. Their local market teams promised both deal sourcing and risk management. Their four-year deployment window demonstrated discipline while maintaining flexibility. Their programmatic joint ventures ensured proprietary deal flow while reducing execution risk.

When markets get challenging, investors don't just want to hear about opportunities—they need to understand how you'll capture them safely and effectively. 

By leading with stability, following with process, and demonstrating how opportunities arrive through disciplined execution, Ares put on a clinic in institutional fundraising that will likely be studied for years to come.

Real quick...

Does your pitch tell a story as compelling as Ares'? BetterPitch specializes in creating investment materials that resonate with institutional investors. From market analysis to strategy presentation, we help managers build world-class marketing collateral to raise capital more efficiently.

See you next friday,

-PitchDeckGuy

Reading this and not subscribed?