Blockbuster Video Activist Presentation Deck

Made public by

Blockbuster Video

sourced by PitchSend

21 of 26

Creator

blockbuster-video

Category

Consumer

Published

June 2010

Slides

Transcriptions

#1Presentation to Blockbuster Shareholders* by Gregory S. Meyer, CFA 2010 Annual Meeting of Shareholders of Blockbuster, Inc. June 3, 2010 *Excerpted from 6/1/10 presentation to RiskMetrics Group#2Notice to Stockholders All stockholders of Blockbuster, Inc. are advised to read Gregory S. Meyer's definitive proxy statement because it contains important information, including information relating to the solicitation of proxies in support of Meyer for use at the 2010 annual meeting of stockholders of Blockbuster, Inc. The definitive proxy statement and GOLD proxy card will be mailed to the stockholders of Blockbuster, Inc. and are also available at no charge on the Securities and Exchange Commission's website at www.sec.gov.#3Summary Situation Summary: Opposing Gary J. Fernandes Change is warranted at Blockbuster ("BBI") ■ ■ Poor stock performance Poor financial performance Poor operational performance: failed execution of multi-channel strategy Blockbuster's Board has failed to protect shareholders Low stock ownership of current directors - Lack of relevant industry expertise Fernandes: History of Failure to Add Value and Poor Judgment Meyer is a highly qualified, industry relevant, stockholder-aligned, independent candidate - Background/Industry Experience/History of Sound Strategic Advice Greater stock ownership = greater aligned interests with shareholders Actively working on plan to address BBI's challenges/3-Phase Plan for Turnaround We asking shareholders to return a GOLD proxy card and vote for Meyer#4Situation Summary Annual Meeting of Shareholders: June 24, 2010 (delayed from original date of May 26, 2010) Meyer initially identified two Blockbuster directors who did not appear to serve the best interests of shareholders: James W. Crystal and Gary J. Fernandes Meyer initially opposed Mr. Crystal. Blockbuster Board announced on May 21, 2010 that Crystal would not stand for re-election Meyer revised proxy materials to oppose Gary J. Fernandes due to: 5 years of failure to produce shareholder value Low share ownership Lack of relevant industry experience - Overly cozy relationship with Blockbuster CEO/Chairman Jim Keyes#5Gary J. Fernandes has sat on Blockbuster's board for 5+ years during a period of significant market share erosion and financial underperformance CHANGE IS WARRANTED AT BLOCKBUSTER We ask all shareholders to return a GOLD proxy card and vote for Meyer#6Blockbuster Stock Performance Since 2005 ■ Equity Market Cap of Blockbuster was > $1.6 billion when Fernandes joined the board in 2004. Today the equity market cap is < $75 million. This represents a loss of over $1.5 billion to shareholders in Blockbuster since Fernandes joined the Board. $1 invested in Blockbuster stock in 12/04 is worth $.05 today $1 invested in Netflix stock in 12/04 is worth> $9.00 today $1 invested in the Hemscott Group Index* in 12/04 is worth $1.30 today Board accountability would suggest that the status quo is not serving the interests of BBI shareholders. The Hemscott Group Index consists of the following issuers: Blockbuster Inc. (Class A common stock); Hastings Entertainment, Inc.; Interlink-US-Network, Ltd.; Netflix, Inc.; Trans World Entertainment Corporation; and Xinhua China Ltd.#7Blockbuster has Significantly Underperformed Peer Group Since Fernandes Joined the Board in December 2004 DOLLARS 150 125 100 S&P 500 Index 75 25 0 12/04 Blockbuster Inc. Class A common stock Hemscott Group Index* COMPARISON OF 5-YEAR CUMULATIVE TOTAL RETURN AMONG BLOCKBUSTER INC. CLASS A. THE S&P 500 INDEX AND HEMSCOTT GROUP INDEX* 12/05 12/06 BLOCKBUSTER INC CLASS A S&P 500 INDEX 1./08 -HEMSCOTT GROUP INDEX" 12/04 100.00 100.00 1/09 100.00 16/05 39.48 91.46 12/06 55.69 91.15 1/10 1/08 36.00 1/09 13.68 7.05 104.91 121.48 128.16 80.74 102.11 The Hemscott Group Index consists of the following issuers: Blockbuster Inc. (Class A common stock); Hastings Entertainment, Inc.; Interlink-US-Network, Ltd.; Netflix, Inc.; Trans World Entertainment Corporation; and Xinhua China Ltd. Table and graph taken from Blockbuster Inc.'s 10-K filed 3/16/10. 78.67 75.74 130.31 6#8Poor Financial Performance and Forecasting = Missed Guidance and Loss of Credibility, but Not Loss of Bonus ■ ■ Overall consumer spending on DVD and Blu-ray rentals was up in 2009. Rentrak Corp. reports rental spending having increased 4.2 percent to $6.5 billion for the year However, in 2009 BBI twice missed guidance, even after re-affirming such guidance to investors just months before period end 2009 EBITDA Guidance Missed Twice: March 2009: 2009 Fiscal EBITDA Guidance originally set at $305 to $325 million May 2009: Guidance re-affirmed Aug 2009: Guidance lowered to $270-$290 million Nov 2009 Guidance re-affirmed Jan 2010: Guidance lowered drastically to $195-$205 million Credibility crisis at the financial controls level Despite missing guidance twice, the Compensation Committee, chaired by Gary Fernandes, awarded CEO Jim Keyes 80% of his target bonus and CFO Thomas Casey 100% of his target bonus for the year 2009. Additionally, in 2010 CFO Casey's salary was increased from $500,000 to $650,000 and he was granted a $400,000 retention bonus, despite continued weak financial performance and a plunging stock price. Bonus partially awarded upon completion of ‘restructuring' regardless of outcome to stock price (single performance metric not aligned with shareholder interests).#9Poor Execution of its Multi-Channel Distribution Strategy While Blockbuster's base of brick-and-mortar stores have suffered, it's multi-channel strategy has been poorly executed: Online/By Mail Subscribers: As of December 31, 2005, there were approximately 1.2 million BLOCKBUSTER Online subscribers vs. 4.2 million for Netflix, a difference of 3 million. As of December 31, 2010, Netflix had grown to over 12 million subscribers while Blockbuster had last reported just 1.6 million subscribers as of October 2009. For every one subscriber Blockbuster added during that time period, Netflix added 20. Kiosks: Redbox locations grew from <200 in early 2005 to 24,000+ kiosks during Fernandes' tenure on the Blockbuster Board, generating $773.5 million in revenue in 2009 from kiosks. To date, Blockbuster has not reported a single dollar of revenue from its kiosk deal with NCR, due to poorly negotiated terms- yet these very kiosks are competing with Blockbuster's own stores.#10Blockbuster Directors Have Extremely Low Stock Ownership Stock Ownership of Non-Management Blockbuster Director Nominees is shockingly low The average stock ownership of Blockbuster's six non-management director nominees is 169,511 'A' shares. This represents < 28% of the stock owned by Mr. Meyer's 620,000 'A' shares. The current market value of this average 169,511 shares is less than $60,000 at the current share price of $.35 per share. How can shareholders feel that the interests of this Board are aligned with their interests with such low stock ownership? We ask all shareholders to return a GOLD proxy card and vote for Meyer 9#11Fernandes has No Relevant Home Entertainment Industry Experience ■ Fernandes has no operating experience in the video rental industry nor in the broader home entertainment industry BBI proxy statement claims "Mr. Fernandes brings technology expertise to the Board through his executive management experience at several technology-based companies, including EDS," a firm he left over 12 years ago. What good has Mr. Fernandes' 'technology expertise' done for BBI stockholders who have watched the company lose significant market share to competitors that outmaneuvered it using innovative technologies such as DVD rental kiosks (Redbox) and streaming video (Netflix)? Any expertise Fernandes had in applied software from his EDS days has clearly not translated into an ability to intelligently navigate the home entertainment sector not to add value for BBI shareholders 10#12Fernandes and Keyes Relationship: Too Cozy Mr. Fernandes was on the Board of 7-Eleven, Inc. the entire time that Jim Keyes was CEO of that company from 2000 to 2005 Fernandes and Keyes, among others, were named defendants in ■ several 2005 shareholder lawsuits regarding 7-Eleven alleging breach of fiduciary duties owed to shareholders in connection with an inadequate ■ 1 Mr. Fernandes was a member of Blockbuster's Nominating Committee during the search that resulted in Mr. Keyes being appointed CEO of BBI in 2007 Fernandes was Chair of BBI's Compensation Committee in 2009 when Keyes was awarded 80% of his target bonus despite financial results that missed guidance twice and a stock price that was down 50% on the year Is Fernandes able to be objective with respect to Keyes given their past history and close personal relationship?#13Fernandes: History of Value Destruction or Stagnation Mr. Fernandes is the longest serving director candidate up for re-election on the Blockbuster Board, having overseen more destruction in shareholder value than any other director nominee Other companies affiliated with Mr. Fernandes have not faired very well either: Mr. Fernandes joined the Board of Computer Associates, now CA Technologies, in May 2003 Since that time, the stock price of CA has shown roughly a 0% return compared to +40% return for IBM, +181% return for ORCL and +250% return for HPQ Per Blockbuster's proxy statement, in November 1998, Fernandes founded Voyagers The Travel Store Holdings, Inc., a chain of travel agencies, and was President and sole shareholder of Voyagers. Voyagers filed a petition under Chapter 7 of the federal bankruptcy laws in October 2001.#14Fernandes Repeatedly Exhibited Questionable Judgment Fernandes on Board when Meyer sent 2005 letter (Exhibit 1) urging Blockbuster to develop a kiosk strategy to save the Company $140 million per year Recommendation was ignored to the detriment of Blockbuster shareholders in the ensuing years Fernandes was on the Blockbuster Board that gave 'full support' of offer to buy failed electronics chain Circuit City in 2008 at a time when Blockbuster should have been focusing on its core operations An expensive and distracting decision at a critical time when Netflix and Redbox were gaining significant market share in the DVD rental segment Related Party Transaction: Fernandes holds interest in 2 real estate partnerships that lease buildings to Blockbuster Despite the closing of thousands of BBI locations over the past several years, the stores owned by Fernandes' partnerships have remained open Material or not, this exhibits poor judgment#15Diversity of Age on BBI Board is Lacking 6 of the 7 Netflix directors are ≤ 52 yrs of age 0 of the 7 Blockbuster director nominees are < 52 yrs of age Average age of BBI Board candidates is 61.7 vs. 51.4 for NFLX and 53.71 for CSTR ■ This is inconsistent with Blockbuster's Nomination Committee Charter which states: The Nominating Committee has the responsibility to "review with the Board the current composition of the Board in light of the characteristics of independence, diversity, age, skills, experience, availability of service to the Company and tenure of its members, and of the Board's anticipated needs"#16■ Reason for the Solicitation Board has not acted in the best interests of its stockholders Board lacks sufficient expertise and alignment of interest w/stockholders Current board has presided over massive destruction of shareholder value and is asking shareholders to support the status quo To replace a director with minimal home entertainment industry experience, relatively low share ownership, and a five year governance track record of year over year dramatic share value erosion Meyer seeks only one of seven board seats This represents a moderate proposal to bring one highly qualified, independent director with significant industry experience to act as a shareholder advocate to the Board of Blockbuster to replace a director who has had over 5 years on the board, has significantly lower share ownership, and no experience in the home entertainment industry Meyer is not seeking control of the Board#17Background on Gregory S. Meyer, CFA Strong Industry and Financial Experience Founded DVDXpress in 2001 Pioneer in DVD rental kiosk channel Grew to 1000 locations in 30 states and the UK, serving millions of customers Sold to Coinstar in 2007, Merged with Redbox division in 2009 Meyer headed DVDXpress line of business at Coinstar through 2009 when it was merged with Redbox - - - Experience is relevant and recent Strong financial background Fixed income trading experience at bulge bracket investment bank- valuable given BBI's debt-heavy cap structure Dartmouth Economics Major summa cum laude Dartmouth Tuck MBA with focus on Finance/Accounting Chartered Financial Analyst Designation Qualifies as Audit Committee Financial Expert -#18Meyer has Relevant Industry Experience Knowledge of Kiosk Industry and how to improve the relationship with NCR to result in an improved economic outcome for BBI ■ ■ Knowledge of how to effectively address kiosk competitors Broad and deep understanding of all aspects of the home entertainment retail marketplace including: brick-and-mortar stores, by-mail, kiosk-based, and online distribution strategies for home entertainment products Ability to improve structure and execution of the deal- many mistakes being made now International Operating Experience: useful for kiosk/ON DEMAND expansion to Europe and sale of European store-based assets Industry Contacts: Direct call access to C-level executives at all major home entertainment distribution companies Brick-and-mortar chains (private) - - Technology providers Content providers Distributors, rack-jobbers, and salvage companies#19Track Record of Sound Strategic Advice In 2004, Meyer met with Blockbuster EVP, Finance, Strategic Planning and Development Frank Paci to review the strategic case for Blockbuster's involvement in the DVD rental kiosk channel ■ In 2005, Meyer sent a formal letter to a key member of Blockbuster's Board of Directors alerting them of the need to enter the DVD rental kiosk channel as a way to reduce costs by $140 million annually and provide a new level of convenience for customers The Blockbuster Board and management ignored the suggestion and the channel altogether allowing competitor Redbox to expand to over 24,000 locations and an expected 2010 video rental market share approaching 30% A copy of the letter was filed as a DFAN14A by Meyer on April 12, 2010#20Meyer Stock Ownership Significantly Greater than Fernandes' 700000 600000 500000 400000 300000 200000 100000 0 Meyer Shares Even after 5 years of equity grants, Fernandes still holds significantly fewer shares than Meyer Fernandes Shares 'B' Shares 'A' Shares 19#21Adding Meyer Brings Age Distribution of BBI Board Closer to Industry Norm Board of Directors Average Age High Age Low Age Netflix 51.43 66 42 Coinstar 53.71 67 34 BBI w/ Fernandes 61.71 80 52 BBI w/ Meyer 57.71 80 38 6 of the 7 Netflix directors are ≤ 52 yrs of age 0 of the 7 Blockbuster director nominees are < 52 yrs of age •Average age of BBI Board candidates is 61.7 vs. 51.4 for NFLX and 53.71 for CS •From Blockbuster's Nomination Committee Charter: -The Nominating Committee has the responsibility to "review with the Board the current composition of the Board in light of the characteristics of independence, diversity, age, skills, experience, availability of service to the Company and tenure of its members, and of the Board's anticipated needs" 20#22Meyer's 3 Phase Plan for Blockbuster Turnaround Phase 1: Address Immediate Liquidity Challenge Viable structure identified and in discussions with constituents ■ - Phase 2: Stabilize cashflows from brick-and-mortar store base Same Store Sales should be stabilizing and turning higher due to: • Massive reduction in Industry Capacity (Movie Gallery/Hollywood Video store closures) - This represents $1.4 billion of revenue up for grabs • 28-day 'exclusive' window with Warner, Fox, Universal represents a huge competitive advantage Poorest performing stores have been closed already resulting in a higher quality store portfolio than any time in the past few years Phase 3: Generate meaningful revenue/EBIT from non-store distribution channels • Leverage strong brand and studio relationships 21#23Phase 1: Address Immediate Liquidity Needs ■ BBI's biggest near term challenge is liquidity issue Meyer has developed a restructuring plan to right-size capital structure and significantly reduce BBI's indebtedness and annual interest obligations in a manner that is non-dilutive to current equity Plan involves participation from BBI's key vendors who also have a vested interest in the long-term health of one of its most important customers- BBI is the only remaining nationwide non-discount video rental chain Plan has been vetted by industry veterans, financial restructuring experts and legal advisors, and has been deemed viable Meyer is actively engaged in discussions with strategic studio partners, financial advisory firms, law firms, subordinated noteholders, secured noteholders, and equity investors to develop a consensus on this structure that provides optimal value to shareholders and fair treatment of all stakeholders. This outcome provides far more value to shareholders than the standard 'debt- for-equity' swap on the table which may result in dilution of equity by 95% 22#24Phase 2: Stabilize Cashflow from Core Store Base Drive traffic to stores via intelligent/low-cost/viral advertising. Improve store experience and customer service. Optimize pricing to provide more compelling/flexible customer value proposition. Re-engage alienated customer base (and store employees) to achieve organic turnaround in same store sales. Cross fertilization of store-based best practices from bottom up- why are some stores so profitable and others money losers? What can BBI offer in store that Netflix and Redbox can't? Look at what other successful brick-and-mortar video rentailers (such as the 600-location Family Video chain) are doing. Outsource/Optimize ordering/scheduling of independent titles to 3rd party to reduce costs and improve flow of customers into stores between major releases ■ Optimize portfolio of physical stores per Movie Gallery/Hollywood Video closures and look for lease re-negotiation opportunities, smaller footprint, retail sublease opportunities Continue to reduce costs: SG&A in Q1 2010 > Q1 2009 despite reduced store base ■ Rationalize cost structure to reflect reduced revenue base: 242,615 sf class A office space at Dallas HQ/850,000 sf distribution center in McKinney, TX, 38 by mail distribution centers throughout US, country head offices in Buenos Aires, Argentina; Toronto, Canada; Uxbridge, England; Milan, Italy; Herlev, Denmark; and Mexico City, Mexico 23

Download to PowerPoint

Download presentation as an editable powerpoint.

Related

Second Quarter 2022 Earnings Presentation image

Second Quarter 2022 Earnings Presentation

Consumer

TATA CONSUMER PRODUCTS Earnings Update image

TATA CONSUMER PRODUCTS Earnings Update

Consumer

Aeva Results Presentation Deck image

Aeva Results Presentation Deck

Consumer

Despegar Investor Day Presentation Deck image

Despegar Investor Day Presentation Deck

Consumer

Vroom Investor Day Presentation Deck image

Vroom Investor Day Presentation Deck

Consumer

Solo Brands IPO Presentation Deck image

Solo Brands IPO Presentation Deck

Consumer

Arrival Results Presentation Deck image

Arrival Results Presentation Deck

Consumer

Bed Bath & Beyond Results Presentation Deck image

Bed Bath & Beyond Results Presentation Deck

Consumer