Investor Presentaiton
Analysts agree with insurers that there will be lower impacts on earnings, cash or solvency than
previously anticipated
Observations
Most insurance groups are expecting
limited disruptions from IFRS 17 and
IFRS 9.
CSM will be the biggest change, as it
impacts reported book value negatively.
Performance KPIs are shifting to cash
flow-based metrics.
IFRS 17 will lift reported RoE - this could
flow through to higher valuations.
What analysts are saying
66
We think UK annuity writers are set to see the greatest noise from IFRS 17 but valuations should not
change for any insurers. Cash, dividends and solvency are unchanged. Fair IFRS PE ratios need to be
adjusted to reflect the new paradigm. - BofA
66
The CSM is the biggest change. We view the treatment of new business gains, essentially "unearned
profits" which are capitalized under IFRS 4 but will now be deferred and amortized under IFRS 17
through the CSM, as the biggest difference, which, from an accounting perspective, will lower reported
book value upon transition and impact the timing of earnings. - BMO
66
Many life insurance-heavy names have switched their KPIs to non-earnings metrics, e.g., capital
generation or cash, which are unaffected by IFRS 17. That said, we think IFRS 17 could introduce an
element of 'presentational volatility' to earnings, which could conceivably increase the cost of equity in
the space. Morgan Stanley
66
-
We believe that the change to accounting linked to IFRS 17 is a positive — this is because it is reducing
reported equity and, therefore, is lifting ROE (earnings are largely unchanged) ... Higher ROEs deserve a
higher price-to-book ratio. This is because investing in a business with a high ROE produces a higher
profit. - Berenberg
9
Market updates on impact of IFRS 17 and IFRS 9
EYView entire presentation