Investor Presentaiton
4.3.2b. Postmortem Analysis: Multi-Sector Collaboration (2)
Slide No. 35
The Nuclear Sector Is An Epitome of Japan's Stovepipe Culture
Stovepipe Culture of the Nuclear Energy Sector (both Business and Academic) Has Led to
(a) Lack of Transparency, and Rigid and Empty Formalism,
(b) Lack of Inter-disciplinary Communication among Academics
(c) Negligence of Closely Related Fields and Multidisciplinary Approaches to Develop
Safety Measures,
(d) Resultantly, an Obsolescent, Vulnerable, Ineffective and Inefficient Safety Scheme, and
(f) Danger of Knowledge Loss (by reducing the number of prospectively competent researchers).
• Collect findings
•
Reflect experts' and residents' voices
International trend
Collect findings
Collect findings
Experts
Development/Revision Process of Regulation and Guide
• Develop ideal regulation
Regulatory authorities
Concerned Residents
Voices
Set standards
Regulatory authorities
Draft regulations
(for discussion)
Voices
Ideal standards
necessary for safety
(for discussion)
• Reflect operators' views
on effectiveness
Regulatory authorities
Hear opinions
Ideal standards
necessary for safety
Turning
Voices/
Negotiations
Operators
• Establish realistic regulations
while maintaining ideal safety
Ideal regulations for securing
rational safety
Open to public
•
Collect findings
Lobbying from operators to experts
and regulatory bodies
• Adjust possible effects on existing
reactors
International trend
Collect
findings
• Develop safety standards as
plausible safety measures while
not decommissioning
• Operators propose the details
for regulation
Ask to
Experts
propose
Voices
detailed
contents
Regulatory authorities
Lobbying
Operators
Lobbying
Operators
Regulatory authorities
Set standards
Review details
Regulations to be compiled
without decommissioning
any existing reactors
Source: NAIIC, Final Report, Table 5.2-1.
• Experts opinions as
"approval"
• Operators' voices heard
to make adjustments
Regulatory authorities
Hear opinions
Regulations to be complied
without decommissioning
any existing reactors
Fine-
tuning
Voices
Experts
Voices
Operators
Open to public
• Establish plausible
standards to save face
without decommissioning
any existing reactors
Regulations to be complied
without decommissioning
any existing reactors
Jun KURIHARA, Canon Institute for Global Studies (CIGS)View entire presentation