Environmental & Social Safeguards Third-Party Monitoring
environmental impact as more resource-efficient Arazi Records Centers (ARCs) will lead to a
lower carbon footprint. The project activities, however, have some environmental risks that
would mainly stem from expansion of ARCS under Components 3 and 4. The accompanying
office renovation works can have Occupational Health and Safety (OHS) risks to labor and
surrounding communities, including air and noise emissions. The procurement of ICT
equipment may pose health and safety risks if electronic waste (e-waste) is not properly
managed. The Government of Punjab through the Board of Revenue (BOR) has conducted a
detailed Environmental and Social (E&S) assessment using a framework approach; and
prepared an Environmental and Social Management Framework (ESMF) including an e-waste
management plan in accordance with the relevant ESF standards.
The social risk rating is High because land tenure is a highly contentious issue in Punjab,
particularly in the context of widening social and economic inequities. In Pakistan, land disputes
typically take the form of inheritance related issues amongst multiple heirs; there is widespread
practice of not allowing women to claim inheritance; usually there are multiple claimants for
properties who often rely on falsified documentation etc. Disputes over land ownership are
likely to emerge as cadastral maps are updated and properties registered. Some level of social
disharmony can also be anticipated, given widespread disputes over land (multiple claimants,
disputed inheritance rights, customary exclusion of women and minors from rightful land
shares, etc.).
Resettlement Policy Framework (RPF) has been prepared by the BoR to address risks related
to land acquisition, restrictions on land use and involuntary resettlement in accordance with
ESS5. There will be no forced evictions under the Project; removal of illegal occupants will
only be done in a manner consistent with basic principles of due process.
The Project is a major reform initiative that requires detailed consultations with stakeholders.
Stakeholders include both those who are affected by the project and those who do not
experience direct impacts, but who have an interest in how the project proceeds. PULSE
stakeholders include landowners and property owners, real estate renters and buyers, housing
societies and property developers, residents of regularized and non-regularized informal
settlements (Katchi Abadis), surveyors, revenue officials, elected representatives, and the
general public.
As per World Bank requirements, Grievance Redressal Mechanism (GRM) systems are an
integral component of the project administration. The Stakeholder Engagement Plan (SEP)
describes the Project GRM in detail. For the Project, a Grievance Redress Committee (GRC)
will be constituted at the PMU, managed by a GRM specialist. A GRM Committee, chaired by
BOR, and comprising all relevant departments will be notified which will draw on existing
resources at the PLRA and BoR.
The Labor Management Plan (LMP) provides estimates of the total number and type of staffing
needed for the Project. The Project does not involve major civil works, and as such there is little
likelihood of there being any large scale in-migration of labor on project sites. Possible labor
risks have been assessed in the SEP and relate to Forced Labor or Child Labor hiring by
2 | PageView entire presentation