Avalara Q2 2022 Financial Analysis
In Our View, Avalara Overstates the Independence of Its Board
Avalara has strong board oversight, with experienced independents
and robust M&A transaction experience
Avalara
82%
Independent Board
1
Bruce Crawford
Robin Foote
Edward Gilhuly
SVP of Jacobs, Former CIO of US Army
Partner of Novantas
Founder of Sageview Capital
Bill Ingram
Marcela Martin
Scott McFarlane
2
3+ Month
Former CFO of Avalara
President of BuzzFeed
Cofounder and CEO of Avalore
Review Process
Tami Reller
Brian Sharples
Rajeev Singh
2
CEO of Duly Health and Care
Cofounder and former CEO of HomeAway
11
CEO of Accolade
3
Board Meetings Held during the
Process
Srinivas Tallapragada
Kathy Zwickert
Independent Directors
Chief Engineering Officer of Salesforce
Former Chief People Officer of NetSuite
18
3
Avalara appears to count as "independent” two directors with longstanding
relationships with Vista, its principals and its portfolio companies
Marcela Martin serves on the Board of a Vista-controlled company, Cvent, with
four other Vista professionals, including the Vista partner responsible for the
Avalara deal1
Rajeev Singh has served on the board of a company that Vista acquired²
The Company suggests a three-month sale process is exceptional or evidence
that the Board's sale process was particularly robust; in reality, a three-month
process is merely typical³
The number of meetings does not, in our view, have any bearing on how
comprehensive the process was or how aggressively the Board negotiated on
behalf of shareholders; we do not believe this is a particularly relevant data point
Avalara neglects to mention that its CEO stands to realize approximately $30 million in golden parachute compensation as a result
of this transaction; 4 we believe this would have been a vastly more attractive outcome to him than the "leadership changes" that
the Board was apparently contemplating
1 Source: Avalara Definitive Proxy Statement, filed with the SEC on September 12, 2022, at page 60.
3 Analysis of the length of the sale processes among the companies used by Avalara's financial advisor in its Selected Transactions Analysis, the average length of the sale process was 3.2 months.
2 Id.
11
4 Source: Avalara Definitive Proxy Statement, filed with the SEC on September 12, 2022, at page 70.
5 Source: Avalara Investor Presentation, filed with the SEC on September 23, 2022, at page 8 ("Transformation will take time and require leadership and team changes").
Altair US, LLCView entire presentation