Investor Presentaiton
Malaysia's government moved away from incremental budget approach to zero-
based budgeting approach to improve spending efficiency
Malaysia
Context
BERSEKUTU
BERTAMBAH MUTU
Previous years budget always used as
baseline for new budget
Set revenue allocation for projects
exist every yr. without a needs
assessment, resulting in
Wasteful expenditure
Increased spend every year
Built in inflation mechanism that's not
justified
What did Malaysia do?
Moved away from copy paste budget model towards zero based
budgeting
·
Expenditures determined from zero each year vs. using last years
numbers as baseline
Removes assumption that project spend simply increases by inflation
and any other cost each year
Forces stakeholders to think from fresh about spend for each
project, break it down & remove wastage
Stakeholders have to justify each need based on objectives vs just
looking at previous budget
All tenders are reviewed and all expenses must be justified
Alternative scenarios provided by stakeholders (e.g.: sourcing
options to reduce costs)
Key successes
Goal is to improve spending efficiency
Already seeing spending cuts
Operating expenditure estimated to decrease
Savings from non-essential expenditure & cost efficiencies
resulting from scrutinizing each expense from base zero
Helps reduce fiscal deficit
Enhances transparency & accountability
Forces stakeholders to think about needs & assess expenses yearly
• Solves problem of some departments being overfunded & others
underfunded
Learnings for Plateau State
Avoid using a copy paste budget model as a baseline and move to zero
based budgeting
Allows for more efficient allocation of resources
Given growing urgent spending priorities, this method proves more
practical & sustainable
Eliminates trap of falling into increased demand for funds for
projects every year (baseline+inflation+new items to buy)
Helps prioritize projects that need attention by having a view
on the needs and expense analysis of each project yearly
Expenditure needs analysis helps to save costs & reduce fiscal deficit
Source: New Straits Times Article 'Government to implement zero based budgeting for procurement process; BCG analysis
259
Copyright 2019 by Boston Consulting Group. All rights reserved.View entire presentation