Investor Presentaiton
•
Pros: Single PBM
Potential decrease in capitation costs
Increased transparency: Allows the state
to set contract parameters and would
streamline monitoring efforts
Flexibility in pharmacy provider
reimbursements
Uniform formulary and coverage criteria
Leverages economies of scale
Potential to preserve 340B pharmacy
revenues, depending on structure
•
Cons: Single PBM
Potential opposition from health plans
Potential decreases in efficiency at the
health plan level, due to multiple lines of
business
Potential loss of provider tax revenue
A PBM reverse auction is an online, competitive bidding process states can use to select a PBM to
manage prescription drug benefits. An auction starts with an opening bid and PBMs submit lower
counteroffers during multiple rounds of bidding. States achieve savings by forcing PBMs to offer the
same contract terms but at a lower price than their competitors. Reverse auctions have been known to
generate significant savings in various governmental procurements. New Jersey used a reverse auction
to select PBMs for public employee health plans and estimates the state will save $2.5 billion in drug
spending between 2017 and 2022.29 While reverse auctions can lower costs for states, bid costs should
not be the only factor to consider. There is a risk PBMs might push cost savings to the pharmacy level,
which could result in low or unfair pharmacy reimbursements and ultimately exacerbate pharmacy
access issues. OHA staff reported several other risks relating to these types of procurements. For a
reverse auction to be successful it is essential that all requirements be clearly defined and
communicated. Any contract OHA considers should include pharmacy protections to ensure adequate
pharmacy access is available to all Medicaid patients.
•
Pros: Reverse auction
Potential cost savings
Leverages free market competition
Ability to define contract requirements
bidders must meet
Cons: Reverse auction
• Less flexible and additional costs may be
incurred with change orders
Provider uncertainty between contract
terms
Upfront procurement costs
In recent reports, the Prescription Drug Affordability Board and the Prescription Drug Price
Transparency Program mention centralized prescription drug purchasing programs. A centralized
prescription drug purchasing program would allow Oregon to privatize, standardize, and condense drug
programs currently run by multiple state insurers to improve cost-effectiveness while retaining
oversight, control, and accountability. This would also increase buying power by aggregating the
covered lives of those insurers and programs.
A few states currently have designated agencies that coordinate the purchase of drugs for state-run
facilities and programs. Programs in Washington and Louisiana purchase drugs related to certain
conditions like hepatitis C. Massachusetts's program administers pharmacy services for corrections,
29 See the National Academy for State Health Policy's article on PBM reverse auctions.
Oregon Secretary of State | Report 2023-25 | August 2023 | page 27View entire presentation