Working Toward the Mobility Society of the Future
Message from
the President
The Source of Our
Value Creation:
What Makes Us Toyota
Value Creation Story:
Working toward the Mobility
Society of the Future
Business Foundations
for Value Creation
Corporate Data
Message from the CSO > Roundtable Discussion with the Outside Directors > Dialogue with Institutional Investors on Corporate Governance > Corporate Governance
Message from the CFO > Capital Strategy > The Environment > Vehicle Safety > Quality and Information Security > Intellectual Property and Privacy >Value Chain Collaboration
Human Rights Diversity and Inclusion > Human Resource Development >Health and Safety and Social Contribution Activities > Risk Management and Compliance
Dialogue with Institutional Investors on Corporate Governance
On April 21, 2022, Toyota Outside Director Ikuro
Sugawara, Operating Officer and Executive Vice
President Masanori Kuwata, and Operating
Officer Yumi Otsuka held a dialogue about corpo-
rate governance with institutional investors. The
following is a summary of their discussion.
Toyota's Communications
Question 1 It seems like Toyota's external com-
munications have begun to change since the
briefing on battery electric vehicle (BEV) strategy
last December. Have you been making enhancing
communications a significant management issue?
Sugawara came to Toyota as an Outside Director
in 2018. Listening to Board of Directors discussions
and various briefings, I noticed that Toyota's people
had a strong tendency to speak in jargon and con-
cepts specific to Toyota, even in external communi-
cations. For example, if you ask about specific
initiatives, you find that Toyota is doing a wide range
of things to address environmental problems and the
Sustainable Development Goals, but when these
efforts are explained in jargon, they don't get across
to outsiders. Effective communication requires not
just putting information out, but making sure it gets
across. So, I began by asking for changes in the way
we communicate within Toyota, and there has been
great progress over these past four years. In the last
year, especially, as we have more actively discussed
governance, I think Toyota has made leaps forward.
At the BEV strategy briefing or at Japan
Automobile Manufacturers Association press confer-
ences, President Toyoda speaks directly to stake-
holders and answers questions in detail. At the
Company-wide level, however, there is still some way
to go toward more effective communication. The
Board of Directors and we Outside Directors will con-
tinue discussions in this area while encouraging
executives to make improvements.
Kuwata Multiple and diverse forms of communica-
tion are key. While the one-way publishing of
information through Toyota Times is necessary, I
think that we should also consider opportunities for
interaction with stakeholders, such as this dialogue.
The Effectiveness of the Board of Directors
Question 2 The degree of independence and
diversity (particularly the percentage of women)
of the Board of Directors seems low by interna-
tional standards. What are your thoughts on this
as an Outside Director?
Sugawara Yes, as you say, the percentage of
female Directors is lower than that at many compa-
nies overseas.
During my time as director-general of the
Economic and Industrial Policy Bureau at the Ministry
of Economy, Trade and Industry, I worked to
advance corporate governance reforms in Japan.
From my perspective, focusing our efforts on real,
substantive discussion is more important than
expending our energy on adjusting the Board's form.
That is not to say, however, that the Board should
remain as it is forever, but that the Board must
approach changes in social expectations flexibly,
from a longer-term perspective. I do see expanding
the role of independent Outside Directors and
advancing diversity as important issues.
Otsuka Diversity comes in many forms, too. Dr.
James Kuffner, as an internal Director, brings a back-
ground in the IT industry and a non-Japanese per-
spective. Working with him, we are gaining new
insights and learning about specific differences in
ways of ways of looking at information and managing
organizations. The scope and methods of our hiring
I have also been changing considerably, with growing
numbers of women and mid-career hires joining
Toyota. We are also revising our hiring methods and
ratios, aiming to reinforce the hiring of software talent
going forward. I think that these efforts will bear fruit
over the longer term, leading to increased diversity in
decision making.
Held April 21, 2022
Question 3 What are your thoughts on the
independence of the current Outside Directors?
Kuwata Toyota's transactions with Sumitomo Mitsui
Banking Corporation, where Outside Director Teiko
Kudo has spent most of her career, are of a scale that
does not hamper her independence. All three Outside
Directors Mr. Sugawara, Ms. Kudo, and Sir Craven-
offer input at the Board of Directors meetings and in
regular communications with executives, which has led
to enormous changes over the past year or two.
Sugawara I feel that Ms. Kudo is effective in her posi-
tion in terms of speaking up as an independent board
member should, regardless of her background. Sir
Craven, meanwhile, comes from a different background
from the rest of us, and he brings unique opinions to
discussions of such matters as human resource devel-
opment and communications. In that way, they very
much fulfill the role of independent Outside Director.
Question 4 Toyota has only three Outside
Directors. Does that make monitoring the
CEO difficult?
Sugawara At Toyota, the Outside Audit &
Supervisory Board Members also take part in Board
of Directors meetings. Final decisions are rendered
by the nine Members of the Board of Directors, but
they incorporate the views of the three Outside Audit
& Supervisory Board Members, who bring diverse
backgrounds. Also, the Outside Directors and
Outside Audit & Supervisory Board Members often
hold study meetings, where the six of us discuss
medium- and long-term issues. In particular, we
spent a considerable amount of time discussing
issues related to carbon neutrality in the run-up to
the BEV strategy briefing. Working alongside the
Outside Audit & Supervisory Board Members, we are
monitoring business execution and expressing the
views of outside stakeholders on medium- and long-
term issues.
Strategic Shareholdings and Other Concerns
Question 5 How do you regard the problems
posed by strategic shareholdings in terms of
asset efficiency and governance?
Sugawara When I came to Toyota, the number of
companies whose shares Toyota strategically held
was about double what it is now, and I was con-
cerned about just those issues. We discussed the
purpose of these cross-shareholdings, and have
since reduced them by about half. We have to be
considerate of the issuers, so these reductions take
time, but we are making progress.
Please understand that we see the problem just as
you do, and we are in the process of making revisions.
Question 6 In light of the news about falsified
vehicle inspections at Toyota dealerships last
year, what do you think Toyota should do to
avoid the kind of organizational problems that
often show up in big companies?
Sugawara In my work at the Ministry of Economy,
Trade and Industry, I witnessed the trajectories of many
companies. When a company is on the brink, the decid-
ing factor is whether or not it still has sufficient younger
talent to support it. Leveraging that talent is the way to
survive. In that sense, I think that Toyota's greatest
investment to avoid the ills of large companies is the
investment it makes in its younger human resources.
Kuwata As Toyota transforms from an automaker
to a mobility company, the partners it works with will
also change considerably. We are very aware that
our values will have to evolve if we are to move for-
ward. We will need to value individuality more and
discard conventional ideas of the background that
top-class talent should have. Efforts to promote the
advancement of women and personnel system
reforms will be gradual, but I hope to work to create
opportunities for diverse talent to thrive.
TOYOTA MOTOR CORPORATION
34
INTEGRATED REPORTView entire presentation