Absolute Return Strategies Presentation
Alternative Investment Research and Education
Research Papers
CLIFFWATER
Webinars
CLIFFWATERIC
CLIFFWATER.IC
Summary
Regulatory Attention
Fees and Expenses in Private Equity
has a
Increased regulation within the private equity industry has r
private
with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as Registered Investment Adveers. In late 2012, the SEC
hanan a two vaar Peasance Exam initiative in order to cain an understanding of the private equity industry and its
o management, conficts of interest,
ed towards newly-registered advisers.
ce Inspections and Examinations has
SAVE THE DATE
Cliffwater's Asset Allocation Outlook Q2 2017
WebEx Presentation
Thursday April 20th 2017
11:00 AM PST/ 2:00 PM EST
A Comparison of Long Dated Funds to Traditional Fund Structures
CliffwaterDirectLendingindex.com
SPONSORED BY CLIFFWATER
U.S. Mezzanine Debt
And Its Relationship to Other Credit Driven Asset Classes
February 23, 2017
Mezzanine debt encompasses a set of junior securities that sit in priority just
above equity and below senior and other secured debt. These securities are
generally non-traded and can be attractive to investors that seek both current
yield and potential capital gains through equity warrants, conversion features,
and corporate control in distressed situations. It is not uncommon for mezzanine
debt to be underwritten to offer a 15-20% gross return. On the other hand,
mezzanine debt can present greater risks compared to more senior securities,
Including weaker covenants and higher losses (lower recovenes) given default.
This report looks at past performance to gauge the attractiveness of mezzanine
debt, both absolute and relative to other corporate securities.
We find that investment funds focused on mezzanine debt produced realized
retums and rick levels consistent with their capital structure ranking and absolute
returns averaging 10% over the 20 year history examined. More generaly, we
also find significant return premiums for private debt compared equivalent public
debt during the study period.
Research Results
Exhibit 1 reports mezzanine debt fund "Vintage year returns from 1995 through 2014.
Performance is measured through June 30, 2016. More recent 2015 and 2016 vintage funds are
omitted, following industry convention, because they are too early in development to have returns
representative of longer term performance. For example, mezzanine funds started in 1995
earned a 10.20% return, while mezzanine funds started in 2005 earned a 4.54% return.
30%
Exhibit 1: U.S. Mezzanine Fund Return (IRR) by Vintage Year
Performance through June 30, 2016
have created
of investors
ctures seek to
compared to
rships have a
5 years. Tho
'um spectrum
d funds
7-dated fi
ding period of
th the current
ad resources,
roposition.
y structures.
companies with lower volatility
s are gonorally characterizod
orago. Long dated funde wil
her not multiples on invested
times net return traditionally
re based on a percentage of
rally be lower (10% to 15%)
the terms to be generally
longer period of time that
potential to accrue more in
nts within a traditional private
oarnings through growth and
Long-dated fund strategies
nd will primarily target control
to compete with their flagship
nd lower retum expectation of
rovided by General Partners and are
o how private equity firms collect lees
nsulting, transaction, and monitoring
from limited partners to the General
ollected from porfolio companies, or
our investment, operations, and legal
understand a manager's practice and
ed in the industry regarding such fees
i manager activity. The managers
of firms that have vidated the law or
ees and expenses should heb in the
ach manager works with its portfolio
ir consulting, transaction, monitoring.
o disclose the various fees that they
of foos during due diligence and in
fwater will eto systematically
crutiny continue progress of
in-house teams of operations-focused
rforming portfolio company work that
for private equity firms to charge its
done by third parties but now carried
ment is often that its foo is compettiva
ed towards the needs of the portiolio
Partner's work in detall with portfolio
and intermediaries who observe the
vestment team works in tandem with
ments, the General Partner's reporting
mants Since audited fund financial
ses paid by portfolio companies to the
er, portfolio company executives, and
fund's govering documents allow as
manager review process begins with
hered and are subject to change without nation
san Ceata hasnot minded an inamlant
iven as to the accuracy or complains of the
read for debuton mmmarchiusa or the that
condestnent adds, and should not be
gs do nd crate an investmont adversant
reuthg from the use of to normelon Past
Mark Johnson
Pate Kaliuotis
Sanior Managing Director
Senior Managing Director
Pete Keliuotis and Mark Johnson will lead a review of Cliffwater's asset allocation outlook for the second quarter of 2017.
WebEx
To join the program on Thursday, April 20th
REMINDER
Teleconference
To join the teleconference, please:
Cliffwater's Private Assets Activity for Q2 2017
WebEx Presentation
Wednesday April 19th 2017
11:00 AM PST/ 2:00 PM EST
Gabrielle Zadra
Eric Abelson
Senior Managing Director
Managing Director
Bernard Gehlmann
Managing Director
Chris Rice-Shopard
Managing Director
Mark Wiliams
Managing Director
25%
20%
15%
10.30
Average Mezzanine
Fund IBR-10.03%
016
loge
دوها
2001
1999
2007 2008
2003 2005
Vintage Year Returns through June 30, 2016
Source: Phich Book US Mezzanine Funds
©2017 Clifwater LLC. All rights reserved.
2011
2013
are large private equity firms
d party ownership, and invost
1-datod investment strategy is
anagore havo bithor utilizod a
fund to one or two conior.
nel firms have raised smaller
Cliffwater's senior private market specialists, will host a review of Q2 2017 private assets research activity. They will discuss the current investment
environment, market opportunities, and the most compelling strategies in private equity, real assets, and real estate sectors.
WebEx
To join the program on Wednesday, April 19th
click on the link below: (No pre-registration required)
Teleconference
To join the teleconference, please:
Dial: 1-800-431-2204 (in the U.S.)
Cliffwater's Private Assets Activity for 02 2017
Password: cliff
If link above does not work, please copy and paste the
address below into your web browser:
https://cliffwater.webex.com
Help
(or 1-847-619-6151 if outside the U.S.)
Passcode: 9610081
If you require assistance during the presentation, please call: 1-310-448-5000.
CLIFFWATERLC | 31View entire presentation