Coppersmith Presentation to Alere Inc Stockholders
PAGE 33 |
COPPERSMITH
▪ Chairman and CEO Zwanziger has been promising growth and increased profits in Health Management that he has failed to
deliver for five years in a row:
Alere & Health Management: No Credibility, No Accountability
Year Ron Zwanziger's Earnings Commentary on Health Management
"... I think we very much we've bottomed out" - 3008; "...we expect 2009
revenues to be slightly up compared to a pro forma 2008." - 4008
2008
"...we are feeling really quite - quite, quite good about what's happening
2009 here in this business." And "...we do expect to have some significant
organic growth in 2010" - 1009
2010
"...we expect the health management business to recommence modest
overall growth in 2011." - 2010
"At this point, we feel that the health management division has begun to
2011 turn the corner and we expect modestly increasing revenues and stable to
increasing gross margins from this point forward." - 1011
2012
"Another favorable trend in the first quarter was improved predictability and
stabilization of our health management unit" - 1012
Reality
2009 organic revenue down 2.1%,
EBITDA margin 327bps
2010 organic revenue down 8.6%,
EBITDA margin 323bps
2011 organic revenue down 10.7%,
EBITDA margin 578bps
2011 organic revenue down 10.7%,
EBITDA margin 578bps
2012 revenue up 0.2% but EBITDA
margin down 485bps
How many years does Health Management have to fail before management and the Board are
held accountable?View entire presentation